Research

How variation becomes evolutionary change

Research in the Culumber Lab examines how environmental variation, behavior, and interactions among individuals shape evolutionary processes. Using livebearing fishes—especially the eastern mosquitofish, Gambusia holbrooki—we combine geographically extensive field studies, behavioral experiments, ecological data, and population genomics. Our current work connects individual behavior and movement with population-level gene flow, investigates how environmental selection maintains adaptive polymorphism, and examines how the genotypes of social partners influence behavioral and evolutionary outcomes.

Major research directions

Behavior, movement, and gene flow

Behavior varies among individuals and populations, but whether this variation affects movement across landscapes and ultimately shapes gene flow remains poorly understood. We examine geographic variation in behavior and correlations among behavioral traits using consistent methods across eastern mosquitofish populations.

We then test whether individual behavior predicts movement, whether ecological conditions explain differences among populations, and whether behaviorally mediated movement corresponds with genomic patterns of gene flow.

Map of eastern mosquitofish sampling locations across Florida
Behavior and movement Consistent behavioral, ecological, and genomic sampling connects individual variation with geography.

Environmental selection and adaptive polymorphism

The persistence of genetic variation within natural populations is a longstanding problem in evolutionary biology. Male eastern mosquitofish occur as either the common silver phenotype or a rarer melanic phenotype whose distribution varies geographically.

We are interested in the biotic and abiotic factors affecting the persistence of this polymorphism.

Melanic and silver eastern mosquitofish collected from a natural population
Polymorphism in natural populations Documenting geographic variation in melanic and silver phenotypes across eastern mosquitofish populations.

Social genetic effects and behavioral evolution

An individual’s phenotype can be influenced by the genes carried by its social partners. These indirect genetic effects may change both the expression of behavioral traits and how those traits respond to selection.

We manipulate the social environment experienced by individual fish to test whether exposure to different male morphs changes behavior, social-network structure, and patterns of behavioral evolution.

Experimental design illustrating effects of genes in the social environment
Genes in the social environment Experimental social environments test how the genotypes of social partners alter focal individuals’ behavior and social-network dynamics.

Questions that connect our work

Thermal adaptation and evolutionary diversification

Temperature influences physiological performance, behavior, reproduction, and survival. We are interested in how thermal adaptation contributes to the maintenance of genetic variation, divergence among populations, and biological diversification.

Our research connects experimental measures of organismal performance with geographic and evolutionary patterns in Xiphophorus and other livebearing fishes.

Tailspot variation in Xiphophorus variatus
Thermal physiology and genetic variation Testing how thermal physiology and other fitness-related traits contribute to the maintenance of genetic variation within populations.

Behavioral ecology and sexual selection

We study how behavioral variation arises, how it is maintained, and how it affects ecological and evolutionary processes. Our work includes activity, exploration, risk taking, cognition, social behavior, dispersal, mating preferences, coloration, social status, and sexual conflict.

We test the importance of sexual selection relative to ecological and physiological sources of selection rather than assuming that any one process predominates.

Illustration of variation in female body condition in livebearing fishes